Tuesday, January 24, 2012
Why didn't the Bush tax cuts work?
1) The 2001 Bush tax cuts were largely consumption-oriented rebates and credits that did little to incentivize new economic production.
2) The 2003 tax cuts were on the supply side, meaning oriented towards lowering the penalty on additional work and investment, and they did improve the economy. Growth accelerated from 2003-2007, unemployment fell rapidly, and despite high federal spending the budget deficit shrank as a percentage of GDP.
3) Unfortunately, at the same time US monetary authorities were pursuing a weak dollar policy which encouraged investors to shunt capital into hedges like gold, oil and real estate. The effect was: A) reduced investment in the productive economy; and B) soaring prices in commodities and real estate, the latter of which became a bubble that burst in summer 2007.
4) As supply-side eminence grise Robert Mundell has explained repeatedly, almost a year after the apex of the mortgage crisis, Ben Bernanke's Federal Reserve compounded the damage by suddenly tightening* money, causing the dollar to soar 30% in three months, the largest such appreciation in such a short time in peacetime history. Tight money sent the over-leveraged economy into a liquidity crunch, crashed the financial system, and broke the economy's back.
5) Since then, the dollar has see-sawed back and forth by wide margins, creating elements of both deflation (tight credit, low interest rates, generally moderate CPI) and inflation (high commodity prices), ensuring continued economic malaise. Combined with pending tax increases and additional costs associated with Obamacare and added regulation, it is an inhospitable climate in which to take economic risks. Investors and entrepreneurs are sidelined.
6) The bottom line is: supply-side tax rate cuts work, but not in a vaccum. The supply-side policy mix requires tax cuts and a stable dollar. The last decade proved Art Laffer's maxim that in terms of economic impact, if regulation is a one, tax cuts are a 10, and monetary policy is a 100. Get money wrong and you're sunk, no matter how good your fiscal policy.
*Note: tightening in this case refers to ceasing to loosen at the expected pace. From May to September 2008 the Fed paused its fast rate cuts at 2%, catching markets by surprise and leading to a mad scramble for cash. The dollar soared and gold plummeted. Bernanke may have paused due to CPI rising to 5.5% and oil hitting $140/barrel.
Wednesday, October 5, 2011
The Rising Dollar and the Market's Decline.
Mundell has since noted he sees little threat of substantial US inflation because M1 money velocity has collapsed by half and is likely to stay down.

In the Journal article, I wondered how Mundell could be concerned with deflation when commodities including gold and oil were rising sharply, and explained his answer came from the exchange rate between the dollar and the euro, which Mundell calls “the most important price in the world.”
According to Mundell, the financial crisis of 2008 was set off by the dollar's rapid fall versus the euro from summer 2007 to spring 2008, followed that summer by an historic 30% dollar rise within three months, the largest major currency appreciation in peacetime history. (The dollar's rise is represented by the steep decline in the euro:)

The rising dollar caused gold to drop sharply:

Oil plummeted from $140 to below $40:

And the consumer price index plummeted from 5.5% to 0% that December, then to -2% in early 2009:

This rapid dollar appreciation caused liquidity to become tight in the midst of the subprime mortgage solvency crisis, freezing the financial system and causing the near-systemic failure.
Despite radical actions by US monetary authorities in the years since, in Mundell’s view, the gravitational pull on the dollar has been back to its strong position versus the euro.
In winter 2009, the Fed initiated its first quantitative easing program (QE1), which pushed the euro/dollar rate down, easing the liquidity crisis. When it ended in late 2009, the dollar rose sharply again, weakening the recovery. QE2 was initiated in summer 2010 and the dollar declined again, improving prospects for recovery.

Now, QE2 has ended, and there is talk of monetary easing from the ECB. These factors, perhaps combined with Europe’s mounting debt crisis, have pushed the dollar up versus the euro, with the euro falling from $1.45 in late August to $1.31 yesterday, a decline of about 10% in one month:

Confirming the stronger dollar, commodities have sold off impressively in recent weeks. Gold is down about $250 since its September high above $1,900:

While a rising dollar is usually a bullish signal, it may be that the Dow’s recent decline is due to investor memories of the last two dollar surges which coincided with tighter money, debt crisis, and contractionary pressures. Today’s market weakness may be due as much to worry about a soaring dollar as to other factors.
Time will tell, but so far Mundell’s unconventional analysis is holding up. Exchange rates -- the relative value between major currencies -- are as important as the absolute value signaled by gold in any discussion of stable money.
Saturday, May 14, 2011
Do Oil Executives Understand Their Industry’s Economics?
Watching the theatrics, one was left to wonder if the executives actually understand the economics of their industry, specifically the role the dollar’s foreign exchange value has on oil prices.
What a pleasure it would have been to watch senators respond to a CEO who, in discussing high prices and corresponding high profits, simply displayed two charts:
The dollar index:

The oil price:

Clearly, the oil price is a near-mirror image of the dollar's foreign exchange value, including the great dollar appreciation of summer 2008.
Instead, the executives discussed world markets, restrictive U.S. regulations, effective tax rates, and a dozen other issues which were relevant, but secondary. The bottom line is, oil prices are elevated because the U.S. government, including Congress, for a decade has ignored (or encouraged) a weak dollar.
The weaker dollar foreign exchange price transmits commodity inflation to the U.S., which is why the oil price today is above $100 per barrel. Oil companies should stress this point every time they get called out for high prices and profits.
Wednesday, February 16, 2011
Wednesday items.
From Forbes, Rich Danker notes President Reagan’s unsuccessful effort to restore a gold-backed dollar.
On The Kudlow Report, Stephen Moore endorses entitlement cuts:
At Asia Times, David Goldman advocates a higher Fed funds rate.
On The Daily Reckoning, Charles Kadlec connects Egypt’s unrest to the dollar’s decline.
World Bank President (and sound money advocate) Robert Zoellick notes high food prices may push one billion people into hunger.
From the Institute for Humane Studies, Prof. Steve Horwitz refutes the claim that the poor are getting poorer:
At Daily Finance, Joseph Lazzaro makes the crucial points that exports are rising, but the trade deficit is also rising due to oil’s high price. Unfortunately, he goes on to argue the yuan should rise significantly which would likely lower the dollar, thereby raising oil even more.
From Heritage, Derek Scissors argues yuan convertability is more important than revaluation.
In The Pittsburgh-Tribune Review, Don Boudreaux explains different views of inflation, though he doesn’t use Robert Mundell’s formulation that inflation is a decline in the monetary standard.
On Capital Gains and Games, Bruce Bartlett cites a poll showing weak support for big spending cuts.
Thursday, February 3, 2011
Thursday items.
From 2007, Alan Reynolds denies that inequality has risen substantially since the 1970s.
Cato’s Dan Mitchell compares economic growth under Reagan vs. Obama.

On RCM, John Tamny points out that oil prices are set on the world market regardless of whether the U.S. buys oil from the Middle East.
At Forbes, Jerry Bowyer links Egypt’s current dollar-related upheaval to past world instability.
On The Kudlow Report, Larry Kudlow rebuts Ben Bernanke’s claims that the weak dollar hasn’t impacted grain prices in Egypt:
On The Gold Standard Now, Ralph Benko adds a third response to Paul Krugman on gold.
At The Daily Reckoning, Eric Fry blames the Federal Reserve for the dollar’s decline.
On The Daily, Will Wilkinson defends immigration.
Sunday, January 16, 2011
Weekend round up.
At The Washington Times, David Malpass advocates a spending cap in exchange for the debt limit increase.
On Fox News, Steve Forbes discusses the dollar’s impact on fuel prices:
At Asia Times, economists Hossein Askari and Noureddine Krichene link high commodity prices to currency inflation.
Cato’s Dan Mitchell cites a recent paper on the negative impact of British tax hikes.
At IBD, Alan Reynolds argues spending cuts won’t reduce economic growth.

On International Liberty, Dan Mitchell calls attention to a new poll that shows public support for spending cuts over tax increases to address the deficit.
Bloomberg reports Fed transcripts show the central bank disregarded housing bubble warnings in 2005, maintaining a cautious rate-increase policy.
On Fox News, Steve Forbes disputes the claim that lower wages are good for the economy:
At Asia Times, David Goldman is bearish on gold.
On Fiscal Times, Bruce Bartlett analyzes world corporate tax rates.
In The NYT Magazine, Keynesian Paul Krugman suggests the euro was a mistake.
Thursday, October 14, 2010
Thursday update.
At CafĂ© Hayek, Don Boudreaux explains that Chinese trade doesn’t diminish good jobs in the U.S.
On The Kudlow Report, Larry discusses rising oil and other commodities:
The WSJ’s David Wessell reports on a new paper suggesting low Fed interest rates caused the housing bubble.
On Asia Times, David Goldman suggests we have symptoms of deflation and inflation because:
When the Fed prints money, investors flee to other currencies, and foreign central banks intervene and buy dollars which they invest in Treasuries. It has precisely the same effect as the Fed’s own buying of bonds — yields fall. This increases the risk of future inflation so the market buys hedges against it (and you should, too).
The WSJ editorial board warns Democrats and Republicans against scapegoating China.
On CNBC, Paul Krugman calls China “the bad guy” in the currency war, and advocates for trillions in additional quantitative easing:
Reuters reports increased unemployment and inflation.
At Conscience of a Liberal, Krugman makes a convincing argument that the scariest part of debt-to-GDP analysis is the weak GDP:
At Forbes, Rich Karlgaard applauds Greg Mankiw’s recent tax analysis.
On The Kudlow Report, Stephen Moore analyzes the President’s NYT contrition:
Seeker Blog discusses Douglas Irwin’s recent paper, “Did France Cause the Great Depression?”
From 1997, Jude Wanniski argues the Great Depression was solely a fiscal crisis.
From June, John Tamny suggests there was a deflationary component in the 1920s.
Thursday, October 7, 2010
Thursday items.
The NY Sun editorializes on the history of JFK, Nixon and gold.
On The Kudlow Report, Larry discusses the weak dollar’s impact on the oil price:
In Foreign Policy, Keynesian Barry Eichengreen analyzes the present currency war.
From 2004, Jude Wanniski and Eichengreen correspond on currency and gold.
Larry Kudlow wonders if this week’s Gallup poll led to the market rally.
At WSJ video, Stephen Moore examines job losses:
At The Journal, Tadashi Nakamae suggests the U.S. is repeating Japan’s monetary errors.
From 2009, Alan Reynolds debunks Keynesian analysis of Japan’s deflation.
On CNBC’s Netnet, Ash Bennington analyzes Art Laffer’s recent WSJ piece.
At Intermex Financial, Ricardo Valuenzuela posts a 2005 Wanniski book review on American entrepreneurship in Jude’s memory.